2026 GRADE A FILMS

RUSSELL BRAND: OPEN SECRET – IS NOT HONEST

GREAT BUT NOT FAIR

I just finished watching Netflix’s Russell Brand: Open Secret, and I have quite a few thoughts.

First, let me give credit where credit is due. It’s a well-made documentary. The storytelling is effective, the editing is polished, and the filmmakers know exactly how to construct a narrative that keeps an audience engaged. Having worked in the entertainment industry and wearing the hat of a screenwriter, I can appreciate the craftsmanship.  Great job.  A+.   But, it’s not honest.

There’s a difference between making a compelling documentary and making an objective one.

Air Crash Disasters and The Foods that Built America are objective documentaries.   This one is anything but objective.

What struck me most wasn’t necessarily what the filmmakers included. It was what they chose to leave out, what they didn’t appear interested in questioning, and how effectively they used storytelling to guide the audience toward a predetermined conclusion, that Russell Brand was the 2nd most evil man on earth, next to President Trump.

The documentary spends considerable time following Rosamund Urwin and Charlotte Wace, the two journalists behind The Times and The Sunday Times investigation into Russell Brand. We learn about their work, their determination to find women willing to speak, and the challenges they faced bringing the allegations to light.

But something kept bothering me.

Where was the actual investigation?

I’m not talking about finding women willing to accuse Russell Brand of rape. I’m talking about independently verifying their allegations, challenging inconsistencies, identifying potential witnesses, and examining evidence that might contradict their accounts.  You know, the stuff that goes on in the writer room – all the time.  We call it plotholes.  

For example, in the documentary, a woman alleged that Brand sexually assaulted her in a bathroom at a filming location while a member of the production crew stood outside guarding the door.  Now, I’ve worked in filmmaking. Movie sets, particularly major Hollywood productions, are busy places. There are production assistants, assistant directors, location managers, security personnel, camera crews, lighting technicians, and countless others moving around throughout the day.

So naturally, I have questions.

Who was guarding that bathroom? Was that person ever identified? Did anyone interview them? Did anyone question the crew members working nearby? Were production records examined? Did anyone witness the alleged public exposure that supposedly occurred earlier that day?

These aren’t unreasonable questions. They’re precisely the kinds of questions an investigator should be asking.  As a screenwriter, I would ask.  But these journalists didn’t.  They just believed all of the women.

All women have to be believed, right?

Then there’s Georgina Baillie.

Baillie has a complicated history with Russell Brand, particularly involving the infamous Sachsgate controversy. The documentary includes her, but gives viewers only a limited picture of her relationship with him.  What’s CONVENIENTLY missing is the fact that Baillie has spoken positively about her personal experiences with Brand, describing their sexual encounters as consensual and saying he respected her boundaries.  She also said that Brand adores women.

But, we’re only going to half-believe Georgina in this doc.   We’re supposed to believe all women, but only half this time for her.   

That doesn’t disprove anyone else’s allegations. One woman’s positive experience cannot establish what happened to another woman.

But why not tell the audience what she really thinks of Brand?

A documentary genuinely interested in understanding a complicated individual should be willing to explore that complexity.  Instead, I came away feeling that information favorable to Brand was given considerably less attention than information portraying him negatively.  I would say nothing positive was said about Brand.

And then things got political.

The documentary explores Brand’s transformation from a left-wing political commentator into someone increasingly associated with conservative audiences, Donald Trump, and the MAGA movement.  It also questioned his conversion to Christianity.  The apparent suggestion is that Brand’s political and religious transformations were calculated attempts to find an audience willing to defend him against sexual assault allegations.

That’s quite an accusation.  But those accusations were also made without any evidence.  Are we supposed to believe that Brand embraced conservatism because conservatives are comfortable with rapists? That he became a Christian because Christians would excuse his behavior? That his political transformation was nothing more than a strategy for protecting himself?  How would the filmmakers know?

They don’t.

I don’t expect every documentary to function like a courtroom. Nor do I expect filmmakers to devote equal time to every conceivable defense argument.  What really got me, not in a good way, was when an actress to portrayed a victim on camera.  She spoke to the camera, 1st person, as though she was a victim of Brand.  The words coming out of her mouth were those of an alleged victim of Russell Brand.   That actress – she was really good.  She cried – she was convincing.  But it was acting.   If she wanted to, she could have took the stand, played another victim, tacked on another 10 years to Russell Brand’s sentence, because she was that good.  How do we know the other women are just that good of actresses?  

Despite my creative disagreements, this documentary gets an A from me.  It was well made.  

GRADE: A

Steve Young

Steve Young

I go by either "Steven" or "Steve" it really doesn't matter. I'm not a professional screenwriter anymore, so there's no need to suck up to me and send me your latest script. I have zero ambition to work in the entertainment industry. I'm now just a regular guy who knows a bit about storytelling, wants to share that knowledge to inspire new writers, and to share my work with everyone!
Steve Young